Lake Horowhenua
activist Philip Dean Taueki is back in court, this time
because he is determined to stop the Horowhenua District
Council endangering the lives of children playing on their
own land.
Lawyers funded by the district’s ratepayers
are questioning Taueki’s standing to bring a case to
prevent council discharging Levin’s stormwater into the
privately-owned Lake Horowhenua.
Dr Max Gibbs from NIWA
warned several years ago that Lake Horowhenua is so toxic
that a mouthful of water can be lethal enough to kill a
child. Levin’s stormwater is a major source of
phosphorous, and phosphorous is the major cause of
cyanobacteria that has plagued the lake in recent years. In his 2012 report, Dr Gibbs refers to a report that 80%
of the lake’s phosphorous comes from the town’s
stormwater system.
As an owner of the lake, Taueki had
filed an application with the Maori Land Court to get the
stormwater out of the lake several years ago.
During a
two-day hearing in March 2012, council’s lawyers promised
to provide within 28 days an authority that would allow them
to pipe stormwater across Maori Freehold land and into the
lake.
Instead, the Horowhenua District Council engaged
Wellington legal firm Buddle Findlay who have resorted to a
variety of diversionary tactics, including strike out
motions and appeals to the Appellate Court.
In their
determination to undermine Taueki’s standing as an owner,
the firm’s lawyers have even managed to convince Judge
Doogan that he has the jurisdiction to consider overturning
a judgement released by the more experienced Judge Harvey
during May this year.
This hearing is scheduled to take
place in Levin on 17 September, and Taueki has been advised
to bring along a lawyer due to the technical issues
involved.
He scoffs at that. “There is only issue
involved, and that is the safety of our
children.”

Taueki, under arrest, after
protesting about the state of the lake.
Taueki is
no stranger to the courtroom. Since he was first arrested
in September 2008 following a confrontation with sailors
using his lake, he has remained on bail while defending a
multitude of charges which he says are nothing but an excuse
to keep him away from his lake. In that time, he has lost
count of the number of times he has been arrested, the hours
wasted in police calls and the assaults, even while in
prison on remand.
But he has kept a tally of the thirty
consecutive charges that he has defended over the past few
years that have been withdrawn, dismissed or quashed on
appeal. Two convictions with discharge, he appealed before
leaving the courthouse because he is adamant that he is
innocent of those as well.
However it is the state of the
lake that bothers Taueki most.
There is no dispute
whatsoever that Lake Horowhenua is privately-owned.
A
certificate of title was issued in the name of Mua-Upoko
owners in 1899.
Nobody can reach Lake Horowhenua without
crossing this Maori Freehold Land.
But in 1905, Parliament
passed a law letting the public use this lake ‘free of
charge’.

Click for big
version
An 1887 Map of the Lake and
Levin
Control of the lake was placed in the hands
of a Domain Board, with no provision for any representation
from the owners.
Within a year, questions were being asked
in Parliament about the repeal of legislation that
‘appropriates a valuable estate without the consent of the
owners’.
Even though there have been commissions of
inquiry, delegations to the Ministers and numerous court
cases over the past century of so, nothing has changed.
It is, says Taueki, theft by statute.
On the very day
of his sentencing on his final criminal charge, out of the
blue Taueki received a letter from the Minister for Maori
Development conceding that such a law would not be put in
place today.
The Hon Te Ururoa Flavell says he can
understand how these arrangements had generated conflicts,
going right back to the early 1900’s and earlier.
But
this letter is cold comfort for the owners whose pristine
lake has deteriorated to the extent it is now rated one of
the most polluted lakes in the country.

David White photographing
Taueki in Lake Horowhenua, with the assistance of supporter
Bryan Ten Have.
It is now three and a half years
since Dr Max Gibbs from NIWA warned that the waters of the
lake had become so toxic that a mouthful of water was lethal
enough to kill a small child.
The response from the five
statutory bodies with a responsibility for the state of the
lake was to set up a Lake Accord.
Part of the Accord’s
management plan is to eliminate or reduce the nuisance
cyanobacteria.
The Local Government Act does not allow a
local authority to create a nuisance on private property,
even when constructing works for land drainage.
But the
Horowhenua District Council has failed to come up with a
resource consent, an easement or any form of authority that
would allow it to pipe contaminants across Maori land into
the waters of the lake.
Taueki is not impressed with the
Lake Accord, stating that it is nothing but an excuse to
extract funding from the Government and set up a few
cosmetic projects that will impress the gullible.
The
Accord has already been granted $1.27 million from the
Government for a Clean Up Fund.
Research commissioned by
the Waitangi Tribunal tends to support Taueki’s contention
that this Accord is yet another in a long line of empty
gestures.

An historic picture of Lake
Horowhenua before it became polluted
As for the
Maori Land Court, he is not impressed by the fact that they
fail to grasp the principles of kawanatanga expressed in the
preamble to their Act.
The irony is that the standing of
this court relies solely on the Treaty that Taueki signed as
the Rangatira of Mua-Upoko on 26 May 1840.
Taueki is, as
the name implies, a great great grandson of Taueki.
As
such, he is entitled to ‘undisturbed possession’ of land
collectively owned.
Undisturbed possession, he reckons is
the right of Mua-Upoko children to wade in the shallows of a
lake on their own land without suffering the effects of
council’s contamination.
This October marks 110 years
since Parliament passed the law that took away the right of
owners to control what happens on their own land and gave
that authority to other parties.
Taueki is disgusted with
the hypocrisy of another Accord partner,
Horizons.
Bio-security consultant Bill Chisholm provided
Taueki with a report that the mere presence of a sign near
the boat club warning that boaties and other recreational
users of the lake about the dangers of lake weed spread, is
insufficient to manage the present threat of aquatic weed
invasion.
While a complete ban on boating may seem
draconian, he said that “boaties should be reminded that
if these aquatic weeds enter the lake, then there will
probably be no boating at all in the future because the weed
mats will make boating physically impossible”.
Aware
that motor boats were not allowed on the lake, Chisholm said
this is probably the main reason why three particularly
invasive weeds were not yet present as they can easily hitch
a ride on motor boat trailers and outboard propellers.
However, he added that the threat from non-motorised
boats and their trailers remains.
Taueki took the
responsible course of action by applying to the Maori Land
Court for an injunction to prevent boats being launched on
the lake until the Domain Board installed a wash-down
facility.
Judge Doogan rejected Taueki’s
application.
A month later, Horizons and NIWA turned up at
the lake ready to launch their motorised boats on the lake.
Taueki quickly parked his truck on his own land in an
attempt to stop them. The police were summoned and arrived,
as usual, in force. Taueki was ordered to remove his truck.
He refused.
Several police officers then grabbed him in a
choke hold and wrestled him out of his truck, even though a
supporter was videotaping this incident. Charges of
obstruction and resistance were quietly dropped after Police
Area Commander Pat Handcock referred this matter to the
IPCA.

Taueki is taken into custody
after trying to prevent Horizons and NIWA launching unwashed
boats into the lake.
Nevertheless, Taueki had
been arrested, handcuffed and marched down to the police
station to be held in custody while Horizons and NIWA placed
his lake at risk of irreversible damage from an invasive
weed.
If Taueki is prepared to put his life and his
liberty on the line for his lake, this passion arises from
his heritage. His duty as kaitiaki cannot be abrogated, he
says simply.
Mua-Upoko was once renowned for its fighting
prowess, stamina, ingenuity and hospitality due to the
native delicacies that once thrived in the lake. Seven
artificial islands created on their lake provided a
sanctuary for their women and children, while their warriors
slept close to an arsenal of weapons. The mutilation of a
high-born Mua-Upoko woman walking alone, provoked a
retaliatory raid on Te Rauparaha and his family, leaving his
favoured son and daughter dead. Escaping naked into the
darkness, Te Rauparaha vowed to exterminate
Mua-Upoko.
This time, Mua-Upoko’s foe was armed with
English muskets. When Ngati Toa attacked Mua-Upoko’s
island refuges, so great was the slaughter of men, women and
children that the waters ran red with blood. Many
Mua-Upoko fled. Those captured were herded like sheep as
fresh meat to feed their enemy, or stockaded on an island to
be consumed one by one, after a tortured
slaying.
Concealed in the Kawiu clearing nearby, Taueki
would have heard their plaintive cries drifting across the
silence of the lake, unable to rescue them if their tribe
was to survive.
Nevertheless Taueki’s allies were
gaining momentum, and even a contemporary biographer accepts
that Te Rauparaha was eventually forced to retreat to his
own island of refuge, Kapiti.
However the weapons of law
proved to be more potent than the weapons of war.

The gentlefolk of Levin boating
on Lake Horowhenua in 1908 shortly after the 1905
appropriation of use of the lake by statute.
It
was Prime Minister Seddon who spearheaded the legislation
that effectively deprived the owners of all rights of
ownership.
This colonial arrogance became so entrenched in
the Levin community that there was nothing the owners could
do to stop members of the sailing and rowing clubs erecting
clubrooms on land that they did not own, and without
permission from the owners.
The leases negotiated with the
Lake Domain Board expired in 2003 and 2007
retrospectively.
The Reserves Act introduced in 1977
prevented the Domain Board from renewing these leases and
therefore in 2006, the Domain Board circumvented the law by
resolving to roll them over on a month by month
basis.
Taueki questioned the legitimacy of this situation
at the time, but was ignored.
One sunny Sunday morning in
2008, he spotted a group of sailors transporting in yachts
and preparing to launch a motorised boat for a regatta
organised without the permit required by the Domain
by-laws.
In court, the sailors had no hesitation admitting
they were not going to let Taueki ‘go spouting on’ about
by-laws and spoiling their plans for the day, even if it was a
condition of access under the Reserves Act.
Instead, they
summoned the police and as soon as the police arrived,
Taueki was in handcuffs and his way to the police station
where he would be held in the police cells while the sailing
club continued with their regatta uninterrupted.
One of
the complainants, David Brown denied he swore at
Taueki.
Obviously he did not realise that all emergency
calls were recorded, because when his call was replayed in
court, he could be clearly heard calling Taueki a ‘black
bastard’ and a ‘fucking wanker’ before trespassing
Taueki from his own land.
The transcripts and court
judgements that Taueki has assembled over the years present
a compelling account of a community that treats the lake as
their own asset, and Taueki as a mad Maori who is the cause
of all the problems down at the lake.
There is for
instance the case where Justice Kos refers to another
regatta that had not been organised lawfully. “There was
no permit for the assembly or event. And there was no permit
for the motorised craft on the lake. Each permit should have
been obtained.
“To make matters worse, the organiser of
the event was a constable.”
To make matters even worse,
that day Taueki had just collected relatives arriving from
overseas for his Mum’s tangi the next day. From inside his
home he could hear people laughing while setting up stalls
only metres away.
He approached the organiser who told
Taueki in no uncertain terms this was not his land before
summoning his colleagues to come down and lock Taueki
up.
Taueki then spent several hours fretting in the police
cells that he would miss his Mum’s tangi.
There were
other cases dropped at the last minute because the evidence
that Taueki intended to produce would prove too embarrassing
for the police.
A classic was the time a rowing club
member and accomplice drove over to his sister’s place
where Taueki had been bailed due to early morning death
threats at his previous bail address. His sister and her
husband ordered these intruders off their property. The
intruders refused to leave and continued to make threatening
gestures. When Taueki was punched in the face, she phoned
the police. She was also attacked in front of her young
children getting ready to leave for school.
The police did
not arrive at the scene until later that afternoon, and then
only to investigate a complaint that the intruder’s van
had been damaged before leaving the property.
Charged with
wilful damage, Taueki served a summons on the intruder’s
wife who had phoned the police that morning worried her
husband would seriously harm Taueki. A senior Government
manager, she informed Wellington Communications that if that
happened, the police would think ‘yay’, before
laughing.
Despite a survey peg marking the Domain
boundaries, these rowers preferred to launch their boats
north of the Domain boundary on land where they had no right
of access. As this site is waahi tapu, Taueki would tell
them in no uncertain terms to get off his land.
Following
mediation arranged by the Human Rights Commission, Police
Inspector Mark Harrison set in place protocols for the local
police to follow whenever the rowers trespassed on his land.
He was to phone the police and take
photographs.

A picture of the unspoilt lake,
prior to Pakeha settlement in the Levin area
On
11 February 2013, Taueki followed these procedures, but the
police notes confirm that the police officers on duty that
evening delayed departure while they checked out Taueki’s
bail conditions, presumably looking for an excuse to hold
him in custody that night.
As soon as the police arrived,
Taueki was handcuffed and bundled into the back of a police
car to be taken back to the police station.
Taueki was
held in custody overnight until his appearance in court the
following afternoon. He arrived home to find his Mercedes
car parked outside his bedroom window trashed beyond repair,
and his camera containing evidential photographs stolen.
Every window was shattered and every panel stoved in; so
Taueki says it is obvious that only people who could have
done that were those who knew he was being detained in
custody that night.

The state of Taueki’s car,
after a night spent in custody.
On 20 July that
same year, a group of twenty rowers blatantly crossed the
Domain boundary despite being cautioned by Judge Atkins not
to do so.
When his supporters arrived on the scene, a
police officer was reading Taueki his rights ready to arrest
him, even though he was in a state of shock, with blood
streaming down his hair from a blow to the back of his head
and a face lacerated after being pummelled into the rocks.
Taueki laid a formal complaint, and when he asked a
police sergeant whether it would be investigated, he was
told: "Probably not."
Six months later, the police sent
Taueki a letter confirming that they were not going to
prosecute the rowers even though they admitted tackling him
to the ground and holding him there for some time. As the
senior police officer reported, Taueki ‘remonstrated’
with the rowers, they believed an assault was imminent and
whether they were trespassing was ‘immaterial’.
But
Taueki says that it is not just a case of trespassing. The
rowers use the bushes in this area to urinate, as rower and
councillor Jo Mason testified nonchalantly in court. From
the window of his home, Taueki often observes people
squatting there, depositing faeces and toilet paper.
Inside a building used by rowers is a sign pointing in
this direction for toilets.
These Domain buildings are
another contentious issue for Taueki. As fixtures, they
now belong to owners of the land upon which they were
built.
The Supreme Court established in 2013 that the
sailing and rowing clubs did not have any legal right to
occupy these buildings at Lake Horowhenua.
In the Maori
Land Court, Judge Harvey had already told the Chairman of
the Lake Domain Board that ‘it would not be unreasonable
to expect that formal notice of the requirement to vacate
the buildings would be issued’. The rowers refused to
budge.
During the summer of 2014, rumours reached a group
of owners that the cyanobacteria had got so bad that year
that the rowers have transferred training to the Manawatu
River, and were storing their boats elsewhere.
By the end
of March, these owners decided to the time had come to use
their own buildings to store their own boats and
equipment. They entered the building, shifted a few items
of no value to one side, swept it out and moved their gear
in.
A day or so later, the police held the owners at bay
while the rowers turfed out the boats belonging to the
owners and changed the locks.
The police then put in place
a 24 hour scene guard to stop the owners from returning to
their own building.
A Police Inspector was dispatched from
Police National Headquarters to meet with Taueki and his
supporters in an attempt to defuse the situation. As soon as
he arrived, he stood down the scene guard. Following a
lengthy meeting in which Taueki produced copies of the
various court judgements supporting his position, Taueki was
given an assurance that this police officer would get back
to him the next day.
That deadline was extended, and then
Taueki decided he was not prepared to wait any longer.
He
re-entered the building, and was removing some junk when the
police turned up. Taueki explained what he was doing, and
told them that they could not arrest him for being
unlawfully in the building, because the previous time the
police had tried to do that, the charge was dropped well
before it came before the court.
In court, the police
testified that they gave Taueki permission to drive his
truck away. He went inside to make a number of phone
calls, and then eventually decided that he was no longer
going to wait around for the police to come up with some
other b*** charge as an excuse to arrest him.
The next
morning, visitors found cops swarming all over the
place. Several weeks later Taueki was arrested when he
turned up for court on another matter, and remanded in
custody on a total of eleven charges, including escaping
from custody.
Four were withdrawn six months later.
Six
were dismissed following nine days of trial during February
this year.
In court, the police still insisted that the
rowing club leased the building, even though not a single
prosecution witness could provide any evidence of a lease.
Dismissing a couple of male assaults female charges,
Judge Hastings came to the conclusion that the complainant
was the aggressor. “The force used was in self-defence and
was reasonable in those circumstances in that it was
proportionate and no more than necessary to remove the
scooter from Mrs Williams”.
Taueki says that it is
absurd that the only charge the police got him on is
escaping from custody, and so convinced is he of his
innocence on that one, he had lodged an appeal before he had
even left the courthouse.
He questions whether any
reasonable person consider himself to be in custody when
given permission to leave. With any doubt or confusion, he
says the case law favours the defendant.
Taueki often
wonders whether he had been set up that night.
When
hearing the charges laid on 11 February 2013, a crucial
issue for Judge Hastings had been whether the rowers
launched their boats within the Domain south of the boundary
peg, or north of it.
At the time this case was heard,
Taueki was on EM Bail conditions so strict that he was
unable to leave his bail address for any reason except to
attend court. As a self-litigant he was denied the right to
meet with prosecution witnesses unless they came to his bail
address at a supporter’s place or track down crucial
documents that had gone missing from his home in his
absence.
During the trial, James
Watson as the complainant, testified that the rowers decided
to launch from the south to ‘try and appease your
small-mindedness’. When asked if they launched their
boats north of the boundary now that Taueki was not at the
lake, he replied: Yes.
In other words, Taueki’s two
months in custody on remand and then release wearing an
electronic bracelet prohibiting him from going anywhere near
his lake meant that the rowers could once again do what they
liked down at the lake because there was nobody around to
stop them.
If anything exemplifies the Treaty violations
when it comes to the lake, Taueki considers that his Supreme
Court judgement would top the list.
As a self-litigant, he
had managed to convince the Supreme Court to hear his appeal
into a non-injury assault conviction following the incident
that took place down at the lake on September 2008.
Judge
Atkins had ruled that Taueki was not in peaceable possession
of his own land, relying on a Canadian case known as ‘Born
with a Tooth’.
The proposition Taueki put to the Supreme
Court was compelling: define peaceable possession in a
matter that recognises the unique circumstances in New
Zealand due to the existence of the Treaty of
Waitangi.
Such was the interest in this case in legal
circles, that Dr Gerard McCoy QC offered to fly back from
Hong Kong to represent Taueki in court pro bono.
In the
Court of Appeal, Crown Law argued that title was nothing but
a name on a piece of paper, and the owners had the same
sorts of rights as the public.
Dr McCoy presented his
arguments to the Supreme Court during a hearing in
Wellington on 11 March 2013.
The outcome was a
disappointment.
The Treaty rated not even a
mention. Funny that.
Delivered nine months later, a week before
Christmas, this Supreme Court judgement suggests that even
ownership of a property in fee simple estate is not
sufficient to establish that a person is in peaceable
possession of his own property.
Over the years, the
Mua-Upoko owners have neither sold nor leased their
privately-owned property to any other party, including the
Crown.
And yet the Courts in this country, from the lowly
Maori Land Court to the Supreme Court itself, claim to respect the
right of the Maori owners to decide what happens on their
own land. Taueki says that these courts have undermined
the whole concept of property ownership in this
country.
“Title is, as Crown Law claims, is nothing but a
name on a worthless piece of paper.”
But he is adamant
that he is not going to let this matter rest there.
He
says there are court judgements going back a century or more
establishing that the lake was to be administered along the
principles that applied before the advent of the Pakeha and
their artifices for creating laws and property rights.
He
says that the decision by a mere Maori Land Court to call a
special hearing to determine whether he has the standing to
stop the local council polluting a privately-owned lake and
endangering the lives of children is the final straw for
many of the owners.
It is now only a matter of time before
the owners seize back control of their own land and their
lake, and he dares the police to arrest those who do
so.
The time for waiting is over, he says. The time for
action is here.
Anne Hunt is an
author who has documented this matter extensively, who served three terms on the Horowhenua District
Council. For the past five years, she has championed
Taueki’s cause, regularly appearing as his McKenzie Friend
in court and providing a bail address whenever necessary to
prevent a remand in
custody.